Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
alert top story

Susie's legacy: 'Her name went on a law that helps every other animal cruelty case'

  • 0

GREENSBORO — Attorney Don Vaughan’s client was the next on the docket when Susie was brought into the courtroom as part of the case being heard that February day in 2010.

Attorney and former state Senator Don Vaughan was in the courtroom when Susie the dog's animal cruelty case was heard, and rushed back to Raleigh to write Susie's Law, which allows judges to give jail time in animal abuse cases, even to first time offenders.

The pit-bull mix puppy, who had been horribly beaten, still had burn marks on her back and most of her body and a broken jaw, and was missing her ears on that day in court as the man accused of hurting her was sentenced for animal cruelty.

Susie now had a family and a protector in Donna Smith Lawrence, who had adopted her.

“I heard the case and I thought it was unbelievable that the judge couldn’t give an active sentence for those horrific injuries,” Vaughan said.

The man had never been convicted of another crime and sentencing guidelines didn’t give the judge the option to send him to jail for what he did to Susie.

The following Monday morning, Vaughan, also a state legislator at the time, drafted Susie’s Law, which passed in 2010 and would become a model for other states.

“I talked to Democrats, Republicans and Independents and it passed 47-0,” Vaughan said of the Senate. “It was the first animal abuse bill that had been passed in 100 years.”

When Susie the dog died last week, the cruelty she faced before being left for dead in 2009 moved not just a community but people across the world as the story spread to books, a full-length feature movie and stuffed animals sold with a miniature copy of the bill attached to where her ear should have been.

01_sh_Susie Update (copy)

In this 2014 photo, Donna Lawrence is pictured with Susie (left) and Big Girl.

More importantly, says Chris Parrish, the assistant district attorney who prosecuted the case, it brought awareness to animal abuse and gave judges an additional tool when evaluating cases that holds abusers accountable with jail sentences.

The law raised punishment to a “Class H” felony, which allowed anyone convicted of animal abuse to serve jail time. They didn’t have to already have a criminal conviction.

“Her name went on a law that helps every other animal cruelty case,” said Parrish, who prosecutes most of the animal cruelty cases in the county. “Almost everyone knows about Susie’s Law. It still has a function.”

Within the first four years, 1,506 charges of animal abuse and 257 charges of intentionally starving an animal to death had been filed against residents statewide, according to data provided by the Administrative Office of the Courts.

Susie’s Law survived 14 different challenges before the North Carolina Court of Appeals.

“It was upheld in every case,” Vaughan said. “What it created nationally was a sea change from misdemeanor punishment to felony punishment with jail time.”

Don Vaughan (copy)


One of Vaughan’s friends, professional golfer Lee Porter, was sitting in a Salt Lake City bagel shop when he saw a crawling news alert on the shop’s TV saying the first person there had been convicted of animal cruelty and sentenced to 20 years patterned after Susie’s Law. Other states followed.

“I called Don immediately,” Porter said.

It was Parrish who had Susie brought into the courtroom that day. And without asking the judge in advance.

“I didn’t tell the judge the dog was coming because I didn’t know how the judge would take it,” Parrish said.

The gallery was full of Susie supporters, who wanted to show their support. The judge found out right before going to the bench and said the dog couldn’t be in the courtroom.

“I said, ‘You go out there and tell them they can’t bring the dog in.’ Not in a disrespectful way — like, I’m not going out there to tell them.”

The judge saw the courtroom was packed.

Susie, with her big brown eyes, laid in the floor right in front of Parrish as the case was heard.

The defendant had claimed he beat the animal because it had licked his newborn’s face. The man’s mother told the News & Record in 2009 that he thought she was going to hurt his child.

“I asked him what he was thinking — and he said ‘I don’t know — the dog just jumped on the couch with the newborn and I lost it.’”

During a break at the trial, Parrish had told Susie’s supporters that while the cruelty was vile, the judge would not be able to give him active jail time because of the way North Carolina laws were written. Because the man did not have a prior conviction, he would likely get probation on that charge.

The man would receive jail time for other charges including burning personal property — the dog — the same sentence he could have received for burning a mattress. He received probation for the animal cruelty conviction.

“I said,’ You have to go to the Legislature to get that done.’ “ Parrish said. “It’s the only time in 20-plus years that anyone’s ever listened to me.”

Parrish did not know that Vaughan was working the same angle. But Susie’s Law supporters inundated the halls of the General Assembly to ensure the legislation passed both the House and Senate.

When Gov. Bev Perdue signed the legislation in December 2010, Susie was there to add her paw print.

Lawmakers from other states and animal activists have called Vaughan for guidance. Vaughan had figured out a way to steer clear of the animal production industry. There are now similar laws in 38 states.

“Our bill pertained to household pets, anyone who intentionally abuses animals,” Vaughan said. “One of the blessings was that Susie already had 26,000 friends on Facebook. They worked the halls of the Legislature and that made the difference.”

Vaughan even took her to the floor of the Senate.

She also went to schools and hospitals.

Her nonprofit and Facebook page help to find homes and the money for medical care for other abused animals. Susie’s Hope also promotes education and awareness of the care and responsibility required for owning a pet.

Vaughan, an adjunct professor of state and local government at Wake Forest University School of Law, took her to his class each year as part of the discussion on getting legislation passed.

COUNCIL_040710__NK_COUNCIL_.2 (copy)

Susie, a pit bull-shepherd mix who survived being severely burned by her former owner, makes an appearance at a City Council meeting in April 2010. Donna Lawrence (front) adopted Susie after she recovered from her injuries.

“She would shake hands with every student, up and down the rows, and then fall asleep,” Vaughan said.

Parrish knows the depths of animal cruelty and the depths of humanity — regarding pets. He said after prosecuting a case involving a kitten — the kitten started chewing on a man’s petunias and he stomped the cat to death — he got emails from as far away as Australia. He said that’s never happened with homicide cases involving people unless the person was a family member or close to the victim.

He also sees the trial as having helped vindicate Susie. When he first met the dog, which was found in a park at just 8 weeks old, they were at Lawrence’s salon. A child was eating hamburgers in front of Susie, who never lashed out and she never lost her temperament despite her injuries.

“It really put things in perspective,” Parrish said.

On the big screen movie about Susie, “Susie’s Hope,” that came through, he said, but Hollywood took some other liberties. Like having Susie’s “mom,” Donna Lawrence, and one of her friends finding the abused animal, instead of the man who found her at a park. Another actor played Parrish in the court scene. But they gave Parrish a sustained cameo sitting in the courtroom with others cast as spectators.

Vaughan was in the movie’s opening scenes and was played by Jon Provost — aka Timmy from the long-running 1950s show “Lassie” — who had 26 pages of lines.

Susie inspired Vaughan to next go after animals left on chains.

“If I ever get back in the General Assembly I’m going to work on that bill,” Vaughan said. “Another Susie inspiration.”

'An inspiration': Susie, abused puppy that became the face of animal cruelty, has died
High Point's Susie the dog had one miracle, so 'maybe God will give her another'
Susie, the burned dog who helped change NC animal cruelty laws, has a tumor on her spine
Burned dog Susie, her owner still fighting abuse
Susie gets chance to shine on ‘Today’
Burned pit Bull Pup doing ‘really well’
Suspect’s mother says he abused dog to protect newborn
A place to heal

Contact Nancy McLaughlin at 336-373-7049 and follow @nmclaughlinNR on Twitter.

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

The committee on Tuesday approved a statement that College Park Baptist Church of Greensboro was not in “friendly cooperation” due to its “open affirmation, approval and endorsement of homosexual behavior,” which conflicts with the denomination's theological conservative positions. In fact, College Park had voted in 1999 to leave the denomination, and its website makes a point about it not being a member of the Southern Baptist Convention but rather of more progressive Baptist bodies.

Recommended for you

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert