Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Edit
Watchdog: Robinson campaign report details 'disturbing' omissions, glaring discrepancies
top story

Watchdog: Robinson campaign report details 'disturbing' omissions, glaring discrepancies

  • 4

RALEIGH — Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson's campaign report does not explain why $186 worth of medical bills were campaign-related.

Or why he bought "campaign clothes and accessories" for $2,840 with the majority being spent at a sporting goods store.

It also doesn't explain why his wife needed to be reimbursed $4,500 for campaign clothing — or how and where she spent the money.

And it says he withdrew $2,400 in cash with no explanation.

The Republican from Greensboro won a crowded primary election in 2020 and then defeated a Democratic state legislator to become North Carolina's first Black lieutenant governor.

But now, Bob Hall, a campaign finance watchdog, has reviewed Robinson's campaign finance reports and found a number of glaring discrepancies and omissions. He said some violate state law and others need further explanation from Robinson's team.

Because of that, Hall requested in a formal complaint last week that the State Board of Elections investigate Robinson's reports.

State elections staff, by law, can't comment on whether a person's campaign finance reports are under investigation. It's unclear whether the board has taken up Hall's call for action.

"We are aware of clerical errors related to our campaign finance reports," Conrad Pogorzelski, Robinson's political consultant, said in an email to The News & Observer. "We are transitioning to new staff, and our team is in the process of working with the (state elections board) to fix any and all mistakes, and to amend our reports to be accurate and up to date."

Bob Phillips, executive director of Common Cause North Carolina, said candidates need to give their constituents confidence that contributions are being used appropriately.

In the past, farmers or tech employees have been able to expense their clothing because their regular job doesn't require them to dress up.

From the report, Phillips said it is unclear why Robinson needed clothing for his campaign from Lake Gaston Outfitters, a store that specializes in hiking, canoeing and cycling gear.

Phillips said he also hasn't seen someone buy their wife clothing before.

"I think it's questionable," Phillips said. "Maybe his wife is someone who is with him and campaigning and there could be a case for additional expenditures ... but that needs an explanation."

And then there are the medical bills.

"I have seen some leeway where people buy clothes or even get a haircut," Phillips said. "But I've never seen a doctor's bill being used or paid for by a campaign contribution and listed in a campaign finance report."

Phillips said there may be a good answer about the medical procedure, but the campaign hasn't yet provided that explanation.

"I'll kind of go back to say it's incumbent on the candidate to be above board and then think about it in terms of how will this look to the public. How will they perceive it?" Phillips said.

Under state law, a candidate can't take out a cash payment over $50 without a detailed description explaining how the funds were used.

Hall noted a $160 expense at the State Employees Credit Union in Kinston, calling that suspicious and in need of further explanation.

"It looks like a cash withdrawal or deposit into someone's account," he said in an email.

North Carolina law allows campaign funds to be spent solely for nine purposes. The first two include expenses resulting from the campaign by the candidate or the candidate's campaign committee, and expenses resulting from holding a public office.

Chris Cooper, a political science professor at Western Carolina University, labeled those first two rules so broad that "a person could drive a Mack truck through them."

"A candidate could make a legitimate case for their own clothing, of course, but if a spouse is making campaign appearances, then there's certainly a case to be made that those could count as well," Cooper said.

The State Board of Elections offers candidates a 142-page manual on campaign finance.

The elections director also provides opinions to candidates seeking further guidance on how they can spend their campaign money.

"The general rule for determining whether an expenditure is permitted is to ask whether the expenditure would have been made absent the campaign for public office or the holding of public office," said Pat Gannon, a spokesman. "If the answer is 'yes' to that question, the expenditure should not be made."

Problems with Robinson's campaign finance report didn't end with his expenditures.

After speaking with The News & Observer, Hall took a deeper dive and found what he said are problems with his campaign contributions.

Hall said in his complaint some of the reports failed to provide adequate information about the sources of the money. He called it "a disturbing pattern of omission that violates state law and prevents the public from having important information about the campaign's financial support."

Among them:

• Robinson collected 1,400 contributions of $50 or more that did not include the occupations of the donors.

• Two donations came from "unknown" donors. One collected on July 7 was for $1,410. The other collected on Aug. 28 was for $100.

• At least 15 donors did not have an address listed.

• Robinson also reported that two federal political action committees donated $5,400. Neither PAC has an address listed or are authorized in North Carolina to make a donation, Hall wrote in his complaint. 

Hall said the lack of information could raise questions about whether the donations were legal and that anonymous donations violate state law.

"This disturbing pattern of omission, particularly from so many large donors, apparently violates (state law) and clearly prevents the public from having important information about the candidates financial support," Hall wrote to the elections board.

Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

Breaking News